Showing posts with label republican. Show all posts
Showing posts with label republican. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 9, 2012

Why I don't belong to the Democratic Party

My sister posted on Facebook, "No jokes aside, I've had several people ask me how I could consider myself a good Mormon and be a democrat. Many many people." She is LDS and belongs to the Democratic Party and that puts her in the minority among Mormons. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has a long tradition of political neutrality. Early in its history most LDS Church members leaned towards the People's Party, a branch of the Democratic Party. As the likelihood of becoming a state became more serious, the Republican Party began courting Utah and its LDS population. In order to give the appearance of non-partisanship to the Federal government, many LDS wards were divided equally among both political parties by LDS Church leaders. Source

  It was in the late 1890's that some modern political issues began making their appearance in Utah (LDS) politics. The first of these was the right-to-work laws. From the very onset the LDS Church took the position of support for right-to-work laws. Unions were referred to as, "Satan's club and therefore destructive of human rights". Church leaders spoke up on this issue, "David O. McKay and his counselors issued a letter to the twelve Mormon congressmen from various western states, urging them to vote in favor of retaining the existing legislation, thereby protecting the state right-to-work laws, averring that doing so would maintain the essential 'free agency' principle." When the Democratic Party espoused this cause it alienated LDS members who wanted to support the position of their leader. Source

When Civil Rights became the battle cry in the 1960's, the Democratic Party was the "Johnny-come-late" to the table. The Republican Party was the party that had espoused the freedom of slaves and equality for black Americans. Until then the Democratic party had been the party that had defended the Klu Klux Klan in the South and had supported racists laws. The LDS Church had always taught that all men were children of God and should be treated as such. The stance of the Democratic Party until the 1960's on civil rights stood in direct opposition to the teachings of LDS prophets. Source It was at this time that Ezra Taft Benson made his famous statement that you cannot be a member of the Democratic Party and a good Mormon at the same time.

In 1972 another line was drawn in the sand: The Equal Rights Amendment campaign was in full force. The seemingly-benign amendment to the US Constitution had some elements included in it that could jeopardize the traditional family and it's values. The ERA fight continued until 1982 when it was finally defeated. The LDS Church opposed this amendment and asked its members to oppose it also. The LDS Church website explains the LDS position. The Democratic Party vehemently defended the ERA and thus further alienated LDS members who wanted to support their leaders. This re-ignited the idea that you cannot be a member of the Democratic Party and be a good Mormon.

In 1973 Roe v. Wade became the hottest topic in the land. The Democratic Party celebrated this Supreme Court decision as a step in the right direction for women everywhere. The LDS Church immediately condemned the practice of abortion and continues to this day preaching against members participating in any way in this practice Source. Once again, the Democratic Party forced LDS members to choose between them and their leaders.

In the 1980's there was a surge of states turning to state lotteries in order to increase their intake of funds. Once again, the LDS Church took a strong stance against state lotteries and asked its members to do the same Source. The Democratic Party once again stood at odds with the LDS Church.

The Democratic Party since then has espoused other issues that have caused LDS leaders to take a stance against them. The latest fight was over gay marriage. The LDS Church took a clear stance of opposing gay marriage and asked its members to do what they could to also support the traditional family. The Democratic Party has taken the stance of supporting gay marriage. Once again, LDS members who are Democrat must decided between supporting their party or their Prophet. Democratic leaders have also supported the film industry in their push to have the freedom to produce pornographic films, they also oppose the filtering of internet pornography and any other restriction on their ability to produce pornography.

Right-to-work, civil rights, ERA, abortion, gambling, gay marriage, pornography are some of the major moral issues the Church has taken a political stance. In every single one of them the Democratic Party stood against them. Is it any wonder that most LDS members belong to the Republican Party? And what issues has the Republican Party espoused that has caused the LDS Church to take a stance against it? I can't think of any issue in the last 100 years that the GOP has defended that the LDS Church has gone against.

Can you be a good Mormon and be a member of the Democratic Party? The answer is "Absolutely YES!" I believe my sister and her family fit that category. But in doing so you will have to go against the stance of your party when it comes to moral issues if you want to follow the advice of the LDS Prophets.

I am a registered Republican, I am moderate on fiscal issues but conservative in moral issues. I don't always agree with the Republican way of doing things but morally, we stand on the same page. The other issues are secondary in my mind. How much is spent on the military vs education is important but not as important as the moral issues. It's not like Republicans oppose spending any money on education or the Democrats on military, just not as much as the other party would like them to. It is the moral fiber of the nation that holds us together, when that fiber is weakened or torn then our nation begins to tear apart. I believe we are seeing that right now.

Modern-day prophets have sounded the trumpet: "...we warn that the disintegration of the family will bring upon individuals, communities, and nations the calamities foretold by ancient and modern prophets." Mormons must stand up and defend the family and anything that will cause it to tear apart, regardless of political party affiliation.

Mormon